Caveman's Watch Forum

A much-belated Watch or Watch Accessories Review Post contains Picture(s)

Posted By: Ricky Lee McBroom
Date: Wednesday, 14 June 2006, at 1:21 a.m.

I bought this one in November of 2004, one of my first watch purchases after being infected with the WIS bug. There's a bit of a story behind it...

I program and support several Citizen CNC Swiss-type lathes as part of my job, and have always been impressed with their quality and reliability. Citizen machine tools are top-notch! And, yes, they're manufactured by the Citizen Watch Company. As I understand it, Citizen couldn't find machine tools with the exact mix of features they desired, so being Citizen, they simply made their own. Smiley That was in the late 50's or early 60's, and Citizen still makes extensive use of their own machine tools in the manufacture of watches.

In any case, I decided that I really, really needed a Citizen watch. Had to be a mechanical movement, and preferably of a vintage which placed it near the time that Citizen bagan manufacturing machine tools. I spent several weeks in the search, considered and, for various reasons, rejected quite a number of pieces. Some just didn't grab me, some were too expensive, too rough cosmetically, etc. When I came across this one, though, it was love at first sight!

Citizen 41 Alarm/Date
CITIZEN 41 Alarm/Date, Found on the Bay! seller's photos

Mind you, the price was, at $125, nearly enough to scare me off. However, a bit of research led me to believe that this was a fair price for this particular watch.

For one thing, it really is quite a rare piece, judged by how infrequently they show up on Found on the Bay!. While I haven't been able to nail down it's date of manufacture precisely, my best estimate is 1964 to 1965. Certainly it predates Citizen's entry into the American market. It's apparently decent condition combined with it's relative scarcity - not to mention it's great looks! - combined in a way such that, despite the fact that $125 is quite an expensive watch for me, I just couldn't resist. Smiley

And I'm awfully glad that I didn't! Even now, going on two years later, it remains one of my favorite watches. I don't know why, precisely, but it is. There's the Citizen machine tool connection, obviously. I think it's safe to say that I'm one of a select few persons on the planet who came to know and revere the CITIZEN brand before ever owning one of their watches. Then, too, the vintage aspect appeals to me. I'm a nostalgic kinda guy and, as a card-carrying Scotsman (well, kilt-wearing, anyway Smiley ), the fact that this modestly-priced watch is still soldiering on, 4 decades after it left the factory, is a major plus.

Mainly, though, this watch is, IMHO, just drop-dead gorgeous. The case is perfectly proportioned, the placement of the crowns perfect, the alarm function truly useful. And something about the way the gray dial catches the light is a joy to me.

Mind you, there were a few dissapointments. Chief among them, the watch was not in quite as good of condition as I'd hoped. It was as described in the Found on the Bay! ad, I reckon: "Slightly scratch on the dial and scuff on the crystal". Better, even. The scratch on the crystal polished right out, and I'm convinced that the dial is not scratched. It is, though, quite dirty.

And the OEM bracelet was sized a good inch too short for me. I am not happy! I had no luck turning up spare links. I tried Citizen and, after the nice phone rep puzzled over the non-standard SN, then realized that the watch in question was 40 years old - well, they were apologetic, and very nice about it - but also no help. I got the distinct feeling I made their day. I've got a mental picture of them going on break and having a good laugh with their colleagues over the silly fellow who called and tried to buy links for a 40 year-old-bracelet. Smiley

After all that you're probably primed for some pics. Here's the first one I took after buying the watch:

Citizen 41 Alarm/Date

Pitiful, I know, but that was the best out of 20 shots. Eek! The wabi is evident, for sure. I am not happy!

Then I tried it on the flatbed scanner:

Citizen 41 Alarm/Date
Citizen 41 Alarm/Date

Still pitiful.. but at least there's more detail. Smiley

You'll note that all these show the OEM bracelet, which I was never actually able to wear. What did I use, you ask? Good question! First, for nearly a year, was a generic black croc-patterned strap. Then, for a few misguided months, a gray NATO. I love NATOs, mind, but it just didn't seem to fit the character of this watch. Then a cheap-a$$ folded-link bracelet, the twin of which you see on so many of my watches. Hey, use what ya got, right? But, alas, while it worked OK, there was no real joy there, either. Ironically, I have not a single photo of any of those combos.

Strange, isn't it, that your favorite watch is not necessarily your most photographed? For me it seems that the more I love the watch, the more I despair that my photography skills aren't up to the task. That's why I hate Kelly so much. (Hi Kelly! Just kidding! Rolling on the floor laughing my a.. off! ) In the specific case of this watch, I think it's 'cause the wabi shows up SO well in photos. I mean, I look at these pics, and the watch looks like a trashed-out POS. But it's not nearly so evident to the naked eye! I swear!!

ANYhow, a couple of months ago I got a wild hair to try the 41 on a brown strap, and after a quick Self-made Watch Stuff! kludge, took these pics:

DIY strap on Citizen 41 Alarm/Date
Frankenstrap!

Some of you might remember them. I know our current WotM does, since he won the modest prize associated with that post... Rolling on the floor laughing my a.. off!

Here are some (previously unrevealed!) shots from the same photo session:

Click to enlarge.
Click to enlarge.

Sorry about the wabi! But I tol' ya' so! Smiley Laughing out loud! Rolling on the floor laughing my a.. off!

The story doesn't end there, though. Couple of weeks ago I finally found a donor watch with the same bracelet what came OEM on the Alarm/Date. Is Happy Day!

Perhaps I should say 'cosmetically the same' for, while the links from that bracelet did fit, they were not identical. I had assumed that the 7 was of a vintage comparable to the 41, based on the bracelets alone. But the 7 appears to be a much newer vintage. A reissue? A Vintage Watch Post bracelet frankened to a newer watch? Who knows? 'tis a mystery. I can tell you for sure, though, that the 41 links have a thin metal 'web' 'twixt the open ends of the links, and the 7 links did not. Maybe that's why the 7 broke and the 41 did not? Smiley Smiley Smiley

In any case, after judicial use of my more advanced watchmakers implements, I was able to make it all work. And here's what the watch looks like right now:

Click to enlarge.
Click to enlarge.

Is Happy Day! Is Happy Day! Is Happy Day! this bracelet!

More? OK!

Click to enlarge.

If there's one slight drawback, it's the extreme flexibility in the XY axis..

Click to enlarge.

..which means it can sometimes sit rather 'oddly' on the wrist. However, this attribute is growing on me, as it also means that this is, bar none, THE most comfortable bracelet I've ever worn. Thumbs Up for this Watch

So, there you go, my beloved CITIZEN Alarm/Date. You can talk about your Poljots, your Vulcain Crickets, your Bellmatics, even {gasp} your Jaeger LeCoultre Memovoxes. But, for me, if you're talking mechanical alarm watch, THIS is the schnitzel!

Just MHO! Contents May Settle During Shipping. Close Cover Before Striking. Your Mileage May Vary.

-Ricky

Messages In This Thread

A much-belated Watch or Watch Accessories Review Post contains Picture(s) (views: 215)
Ricky Lee McBroom -- Wednesday, 14 June 2006, at 1:21 a.m.
Thumbs Up for this Watch That is a great Vintage Watch Post CITIZEN Ricky! Thumbs Up for this Watch A really rare and unique watch. Thumbs Up for this Watch Great pics, too! Smiley Post contains no message text (views: 4)
Zeb -- Wednesday, 14 June 2006, at 10:56 a.m.

Great reading...nicely done Post contains no message text (views: 4)
colbypaperboy -- Wednesday, 14 June 2006, at 4:59 a.m.
Nice Review and great find! I dig the cursive Citz Logo Post contains no message text (views: 4)
sfnewguy -- Wednesday, 14 June 2006, at 3:49 a.m.
Great review Ricky! That bracelet looks like it's an imitation Jubilee and if it is >>> (views: 10)
John Lind -- Wednesday, 14 June 2006, at 3:30 a.m.

What is the lug width? What is the width at the clasp? If you're not as concerned about keeping an OEM wrapped link bracelet on it, and if the lug width and width at clasp are proper, you could replace it with an aftermarket, heavy solid link Jubilee. Transplanting a folding clasp is usually not too difficult provided clasp width and bracelet width at the clasp match. If you're lucky, only the signed shell need be moved. Other times the entire z-fold with shell has to be transplanted. I've done it now with at least three bracelets (those are the ones I can remember). It's not without pitfalls, and it pays to measure things carefully, and examine the potential replacement carefully first. -- John

'tis indeed a Jubilee-style, 18mm at the lugs.. >>
Ricky Lee McBroom -- Wednesday, 14 June 2006, at 10:47 a.m.

..tapering to 16mm at the clasp.

Hmmmm. After going to so much trouble to get the bracelet sized, I'm not quite ready to ditch it. Smiley

But it's a good idea! Perhaps I will go to an aftermarket solid-link Jubilee in the future. I'd certainly want to keep the signed clasp.. even the Z-fold, as it bears the CITIZEN brand, too.

Thanks!

-Ricky

Very cool, Ricky! Thank you! for the Watch or Watch Accessories Review Post contains no message text (views: 5)
Eric O -- Wednesday, 14 June 2006, at 2:39 a.m.
Very cool sir! Thumbs Up for this Watch A nice Watch or Watch Accessories Review of a super nice Vintage Watch Post CITIZEN I do remember the contest! Laughing out loud! I also had a couple... Post contains Picture(s) (views: 16)
Mike D -- Wednesday, 14 June 2006, at 2:33 a.m.
of vintage Citizens from the '60s. I got them both from a guy on ebay in Japan. They are really rare and cool, but not expensive. I ended up getting rid of them, just because I never wore 'em and I thought they should be with someone who would wear them more often. Here is a pic of mine:
Those are sweet! Thumbs Up for this Watch What does the script say.. >> (views: 1)
Ricky Lee McBroom -- Wednesday, 14 June 2006, at 10:34 a.m.

..on the SS one on the left? Right under the CITIZEN logo.. I can make out "Auto", but not the rest.

-Ricky

Thanks Ricky! It says, "Auto Dater Uni" and below the hands it says, "19 Jewels Para 40M Water". >> (views: 5)
Mike D -- Wednesday, 14 June 2006, at 1:02 p.m.

Yours has the Para language on the back. I have never heard a good reason for using that language on a Japanese watch - no idea! Smiley

Good review and a sweet watch! Post contains no message text (views: 5)
Jammer -- Wednesday, 14 June 2006, at 2:19 a.m.
Thumbs Up for this Watch Super review, really enjoyed it, Post contains no message text (views: 5)
davec73 -- Wednesday, 14 June 2006, at 2:09 a.m.
Great find. Not in too bad shape. Worth sending out to restore. Thumbs Up for this Watch Post contains no message text (views: 6)
Robmks -- Wednesday, 14 June 2006, at 2:08 a.m.
Great minds think alike. Smiley >> (views: 10)
Ricky Lee McBroom -- Wednesday, 14 June 2006, at 2:47 a.m.

I do plan on giving this one a full-boat professional restoration, at some point.

That point being when I feel I can be seperated from it from a month or two without going into withdrawal! Laughing out loud!

Somehow, I've come to think of this one as my "lucky watch". I don't know why, quite. Nothing earth-shattering has ever happened when I wear it. No Powerball wins or the like.

Yet.. there's always some LITTLE thing, you know? Like I'll hit every light green on the way to work. Or my boss will leave early on the day I need to leave early. Or a long lost friend I haven't talked to in ages will call.

's strange, but something good always seems to happen when I wear it... Smiley

-Ricky

Well after some Spa Time, I hope you hit the lottery. Smiley Post contains no message text (views: 4)
Robmks -- Wednesday, 14 June 2006, at 3:04 a.m.
What a great piece of horologic history! Thumbs Up for this Watch Post contains no message text (views: 6)
Tom P -- Wednesday, 14 June 2006, at 2:07 a.m.
Thumbs Up for this Watch I've never seen one before Post contains no message text (views: 7)
Paul December -- Wednesday, 14 June 2006, at 1:49 a.m.
Thank you! Paul! I've only seen a few others. Post contains Picture(s) > (views: 18)
Ricky Lee McBroom -- Wednesday, 14 June 2006, at 2:35 a.m.

This is the closest I've ever encountered on Found on the Bay!:


It went for a slightly higher price than mine. I like mine better, so I feel vindicated. Smiley

Careful googling will turn up a few more:


The one on top appears to a fraternal twin of mine. Alas, no sales prices are revealed on this private sales site. I do wonder, though..

This one, which I really like, went for a mere $85 on the 'bay:

But you'll notice it's a 'Citizen Alarm' not an "Alarm/Date". Which actually makes it more rare, as far as I can tell. I almost bid on it, but I have enough gold watches already and, in any case, felt I had this particular segment covered. Smiley

But, yet, looking at the photos now, I regret it. Laughing out loud! Ah well, stories about "the one that got away" are always worthy. Laughing out loud!

-Ricky

< Back to My Watch Collection >